Chris Pandolfi Avatar Posted on 5/5/2012 by Chris Pandolfi
Movies
Reviews
Share This Story
A film in which contrivances are not a narrative obligation but a means to an end, a method of sending a message that’s not only valid but life-affirming as well.

I left John Madden’s The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel prepared to describe it as a fairy tale, only to realize how condescending that would be. Here is a film in which contrivances are not a narrative obligation but a means to an end, a method of sending a message that’s not only valid but life-affirming as well. Liking this film really has nothing to do with overlooking its obviously manufactured plot and reliably developed characters. It actually depends entirely on your willingness to hear what it has to say. Cynicism will not help you here. I say that as if it were a contractual obligation rather than a welcome opportunity to shed yourself of something heavy. Are today’s audiences so world-weary that a positive outlook is no longer welcome in the movies? I find such a prospect troublesome.
Release: May 4, 2012
Rating: PG-13
Studio: 20th Century Fox
Written by Chris Pandolfi (editor-at-large)

I left John Madden’s The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel prepared to describe it as a fairy tale, only to realize how condescending that would be. Here is a film in which contrivances are not a narrative obligation but a means to an end, a method of sending a message that’s not only valid but life-affirming as well. Liking this film really has nothing to do with overlooking its obviously manufactured plot and reliably developed characters. It actually depends entirely on your willingness to hear what it has to say. Cynicism will not help you here. I say that as if it were a contractual obligation rather than a welcome opportunity to shed yourself of something heavy. Are today’s audiences so world-weary that a positive outlook is no longer welcome in the movies? I find such a prospect troublesome.

Adapted from Deborah Moggach’s novel These Foolish Things, the film tells a funny, romantic, and touching story of seven retirees who have relocated themselves from the U.K. to Jaipur, India. Most of them are hoping to start their life anew, although a select few are dragged kicking and screaming. Their destination is the Best Exotic Marigold Hotel, which was advertised as a peaceful and luxurious retirement resort but is actually still being renovated. This means that basic amenities – such as electricity, running water, working telephones, and in some cases, doors – cannot be guaranteed at this point. The owner, the young and hopelessly naïve Sonny Kapoor (Dev Patel), is a dreamer with a lot of enthusiasm but almost no head for business. He inherited the building from his father with only the hope that he could transform it into a hotel.

The retirees come from different walks of life, and yet all of them are in desperate need of a transformation. Evelyn (Judi Dench) is a newly widowed woman who has inherited all her late husband’s hidden debts. Her computer skills are shoddy, and she has absolutely no work experience, but the prospect of moving in with her son and his family motivates her to strive for independence, which she will hopefully find in India. Graham (Tom Wilkinson) has become disillusioned as a successful High Court judge. Having spent his childhood in India, he decides to return and make peace with his past, which involves an attempt to right a wrong that has plagued him for years. Muriel (Maggie Smith) is a retired housekeeper who desperately needs hip replacement surgery and can only find it in India. The trouble is, her years of insulation from the outside world have made her unpleasantly xenophobic.

Douglas (Bill Nighy) made the mistake of lending his retirement money to his daughter for an internet business that may or may not pan out. In India, he hopes to shed his mild-mannered image and experience something new. The same cannot be said for his wife, Jean (Penelope Wilton), a shallow and profoundly negative woman who resists India with every fiber of her being. She finds herself increasingly drawn to Graham, who secretly goes every day to a local hall of records. Likewise, Douglas finds himself drawn to Evelyn, now a consultant at a telecommunications company. Madge (Celia Imrie) and Norman (Ronald Pickup) are both looking for relationships; the former is a multiple divorcee seeking a rich man in exclusive clubs while the latter is a desperately lonely man who missed out earlier in life and just wants a passionate sexual liaison.

As six of these seven characters slowly adapt to the culture and landscape of India, Sonny continues to struggle with the hotel and his personal life, clinging to optimism by little more than his fingernails. He’s in love with Sunaina (Tena Desae), who works at her brother’s call center and is very much modern young woman. Neither situation sits well with Sonny’s traditionalist mother (Lillete Dubey), who wants him in an arranged marriage and doesn’t believe he’s capable of making something out of the hotel. In the meantime, Muriel is the subject of an expected yet appropriate subplot in which she discovers she has something in common with the hotel’s lower-caste Indian housekeeper, who cannot speak English.

Evelyn records her thoughts daily on a blog, in part to appease her disapproving son but mostly as a way to make sense of her surroundings and the new people in her life. Some of her entries serve as voiceover narrations, especially during the latter half of the film, at which point we witness several scenes that are tidy and convenient yet indisputably poignant. She eventually writes out one of Sonny’s lines, transforming it from a desperate plea to a powerful and moving philosophy: “Everything will be all right in the end. So if it is not all right, it is not yet the end.” Would the world be a better place if we all adopted this mindset? I’d like to think so. Yes, The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel is contrived, but I believe its inspiring message more than makes up for that. Sometimes, it’s much healthier to embrace lofty ideals than to blindly accept life’s harsh realities.


Share This Story





Not entirely successful and its sense of humor leaves a lot to be desired; nevertheless, a great improvement over its horrendous 2011 predecessor.
May 23, 2013Read More!
Chan and Wilson's undeniable chemistry help make the Shanghai films two of the better action-comedies of the past decade.
May 20, 2013Read More!
Like its 2009 predecessor, J.J. Abrams reduces Gene Roddenberry's once exciting and idealistic vision to the level of meaningless summer popcorn thrills.
May 17, 2013Read More!
Under Luhrmann's direction, Fitzgerald's novel is freed from the weight of its literariness; there's an energy that has never been seen before, a vibrancy, a sense that we’re actually being told a story.
May 11, 2013Read More!
While light on content, this Kaijudo starter DVD makes a good place for curious new fans to get acquainted with the hit animated series.
May 10, 2013Read More!
See More From Movies...
We chat with Viviane Schwarz, author + illustrator of the dazzling new graphic novel The Sleepwalkers. All Ages Welcome.
May 9, 2013Read More!
Beautifully illustrated in both style and substance; rewards those who give in to its infectious sense of optimism in discovering one’s own place in the world.
May 8, 2013Read More!
We chat with the multi-talented author and artist of Calling Dr. Laura: A Graphic Memoir about life, love, and following your dreams.
April 26, 2013Read More!
We chat with author Ted Kosmatka about his latest novel, Prophet of Bones, what it’s like working for Valve, and writing intelligent fiction.
April 26, 2013Read More!
Sedaris' latest collection of essays is as good as they’ve ever, filled with the same observational humor and honesty that's helped endear him to so many.
April 26, 2013Read More!
See More From Culture...
Improved visuals and controls make this port of the 3DS original the best Resident Evil game to hit home consoles in years.
May 23, 2013Read More!
Microsoft reveals their next-gen entertainment platform: the Xbox One. But can this all-in-one device live up to its name (and lofty goals)?
May 21, 2013Read More!
April sales rained down 42% hardware and 17% software losses YOY, with total dollars spent down a gloomy 25% overall.
May 17, 2013Read More!
A slapdash collection of the same pitfalls seen in the original game, choosing to bask in gimmickry and momentum from fans rather than creating a stable and engrossing experience.
May 15, 2013Read More!
A more accessible experience for those who might have struggled with the first two games, and a considerable improvement over the original release.
May 3, 2013Read More!
See More From Games...